What are the rules we should have on commenting?

As long as people show respect for each other, they can disagree or agree as much as they like in the comments. Calling other members idiots because they don�t share your opinion is not acceptable, so there�s a balance between critic comments and disrespectful ones that needs to be understood and followed by all members.

Edited by UMUR - 16 Apr 2012 at 2:06am

But you're all assholes if you don't agree with my reviews!

UMUR wrote:   ...personally I hope the comments on reviews is something that will be used more extensively in the future. There�s nothing better for a reviewer than to be made aware that someone has actually read your review and has an opinion about it. It�s great motivation.

Well, I say the most insulting thing you can say to a reviewer is tell them their opinion is wrong, then tell them to give it another listen and write a new review with a different rating.

Wilytank wrote: Well, I say the most insulting thing you can say to a reviewer is tell them their opinion is wrong, then tell them to give it another listen and write a new review with a different rating.

This. Correcting factual errors and giving constructive criticism of the review itself (in terms of whether or not it's well-written) is okay, but claiming another person's opinion is wrong is entirely missing the point of what a review is supposed to do.