NINE INCH NAILS — Broken (review)

EP · 1992 · Industrial Metal

5/5 · 2015-02-01
aglasshouse

In the late 80's, Trent Reznor originally envisioned a band that made subtle social commentary which was conveyed via. industrial rock. Thus, Pretty Hate Machine was released in 1989 to average popularity. However, Reznor himself believed that he had overdone it, and implied too much shameless self pity. Feeling that his point was ruined from the release, he planned another release and gave the public the EP Broken a few years later.

Trent, my god, good job with this one. Taking a metal edge instead of the indulgent mainstream industrial rock that the antecedent release was full of, this EP evolves not only the Industrial metal scene but also the band's structure. If I were to say, my favorite industrial metal band has always been Stabbing Westward. However, after finding and buying this little gem at a thrift store, I decided that Nine Inch Nails had thoroughly earned my respect as a whole.

The album ranges from flat out slamming metal to more complex, albeit stranger songs. The future Nine Inch Nails sound is still there, but if you are interested in such a raw version of this band then this would be definitely something for you. 'Wish' is a simple little tune, undoubtedly the most recognized from it, which follows a quick tempo as well as sudden bursts of angry static-style riffing. 'Last' is an absolute slammer, with giant hunky metallic riffs making for a pure ball of anger hitting you over and over. Simply excellent, and perhaps my personal favorite from the album. 'Help Me I'm In Hell' is an interesting bridge to 'Happiness in Slavery', another scream-filled song which Reznor pours his soul into. 'Gave Up' is more of an fast, alternative hard rock song with fewer industrial elements than the others. However, Reznor's voice has been modified which sounds like he's speaking into a fan. However, it does add some more feeling to the song.

Now, 'Gave Up' is perhaps where we would end, for the rest of the EP is simple blank space. But no, hidden at the end are two covers of two different bands. The first being 'Physical (You're So)', a cover of the post-punk band Adam and the Ants, is actually quite enjoyable. The band souped up the original to add more metal as well as more electronic influences and sounds. The second is 'Suck', a cover of the industrial rock band Pigface. It isn't as enjoyable as the former but it's still okay. I would call it more undoubtedly hard-rockish than metallic. Nice casual listen, though.

So, in the end, NiN's Broken is a fantastic EP. I would go so far as to say that this little gem is what undoubtedly got the band rolling. I suggest if you are any particular metal fan or even a fan of the band, get it, it'll be worth it.

more than 2 years ago
Permalink
Report #298592

Share this review

Review Comments

Post a public comment below | Send private message to the reviewer

Please login to post a shout

aglasshouse wrote:

more than 2 years ago

I think that, even though NiN isn't the most satisfactory metal band, this release is something really great. I agree however that I'd take Darkest Days or Ungod over this in most circumstances.

Unitron wrote:

more than 2 years ago

I must agree to a certain extent, I'd take Stabbing Westward's 'Ungod' album over NIN any day.

siLLy puPPy wrote:

more than 2 years ago

Although i like NIN none of their albums really have enough ooompf for me. I much prefer Skinny Puppy and a lot of the bands that were influenced by NIN, however i don't dislike them, just not my first choice :)

Unitron wrote:

more than 2 years ago

I love this EP, it really shows a fantastic beginning of what NIN is all about.