adg211288

Adam Gardiner
Forum Admin Group · Black Metal, Prog/AG Teams
Registered more than 2 years ago · Last visit 11 hours ago

Favorite Metal Artists

All Reviews/Ratings

3245 reviews/ratings
WINTERHORDE - Underwatermoon Melodic Black Metal | review permalink
SONIC PULSAR - Playing the Universe Progressive Metal | review permalink
STAR ONE - Victims of the Modern Age Progressive Metal | review permalink
IRON MAIDEN - The Number Of The Beast NWoBHM | review permalink
DREAM THEATER - Images and Words Progressive Metal | review permalink
REBELLION - Miklagard - The History of the Vikings Volume II Power Metal | review permalink
BEYOND TWILIGHT - Section X Progressive Metal | review permalink
IMMORTAL - At the Heart of Winter Black Metal | review permalink
DARKOLOGY - Altered Reflections Progressive Metal | review permalink
CRUACHAN - Folk-Lore Folk Metal | review permalink
ALICE IN CHAINS - Black Gives Way To Blue Alternative Metal | review permalink
AYREON - The Final Experiment Progressive Metal | review permalink
BLIND GUARDIAN - Imaginations From the Other Side Power Metal | review permalink
EPICA - The Divine Conspiracy Symphonic Metal | review permalink
AYREON - The Human Equation Progressive Metal | review permalink
EPICA - Design Your Universe Symphonic Metal | review permalink
ASTARTE - Quod Superius Sicut Inferius Melodic Black Metal
AVANTASIA - The Metal Opera Power Metal
AYREON - 01011001 Progressive Metal | review permalink
REBELLION - Arise: From Ginnungagap to Ragnarök - The History of the Vikings Volume III Power Metal | review permalink

See all reviews/ratings

Metal Genre Nb. Rated Avg. rating
1 Power Metal 412 4.18
2 Progressive Metal 348 4.21
3 Heavy Metal 260 3.92
4 Atmospheric Black Metal 229 4.12
5 Black Metal 184 3.92
6 US Power Metal 157 4.22
7 Technical Death Metal 122 4.23
8 Symphonic Metal 118 3.86
9 Death Metal 109 4.06
10 Folk Metal 109 3.96
11 Thrash Metal 105 4.02
12 Melodic Death Metal 101 4.01
13 Non-Metal 98 3.87
14 Metal Related 82 4.06
15 Hard Rock 64 3.84
16 Melodic Black Metal 63 4.10
17 Gothic Metal 62 3.73
18 Doom Metal 61 4.03
19 Stoner Metal 45 4.16
20 Speed Metal 43 3.88
21 Alternative Metal 40 3.48
22 Atmospheric Sludge Metal 33 4.03
23 Symphonic Black Metal 33 4.20
24 Heavy Psych 30 4.32
25 Death-Doom Metal 29 4.12
26 Pagan Black Metal 25 3.90
27 Groove Metal 24 3.67
28 Avant-garde Metal 23 3.91
29 Viking Metal 23 4.11
30 Depressive Black Metal 20 3.77
31 NWoBHM 20 4.40
32 Traditional Doom Metal 19 4.34
33 Sludge Metal 18 4.25
34 Heavy Alternative Rock 18 3.39
35 Funeral Doom Metal 15 4.13
36 Stoner Rock 15 3.97
37 Technical Thrash Metal 15 4.13
38 Brutal Death Metal 14 3.29
39 Melodic Metalcore 14 3.54
40 War Metal 11 4.09
41 Proto-Metal 8 4.13
42 Metalcore 6 2.25
43 Industrial Metal 5 3.80
44 Neoclassical metal 3 3.83
45 Drone Metal 3 3.50
46 Deathcore 2 1.75
47 Death 'n' Roll 2 3.00
48 Crossover Thrash 1 3.50
49 Crust Punk 1 4.00
50 Grindcore 1 4.00
51 Hardcore Punk 1 3.50
52 Trance Metal 1 0.50

Latest Albums Reviews

BLOOD INCANTATION Absolute Elsewhere

Album · 2024 · Death Metal
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
The US death metal act Blood Incantation has already established themselves as a major act of their genre. It was apparent, I think, from at least as early as their debut album Starspawn (2016) but really asserted on Hidden History of the Human Race (2019). They played progressive death metal but without over reliance on the technical death metal sub-genre. Absolute Elsewhere (2024) is their third studio album and although they've left it so long between their primary records Blood Incantation has been far from idle and in the intervening years has taken the time to explore other avenues of music, most notably space ambient on the EP (which is actually album length and was until Absolute Elsewhere actually their longest release) Timewave Zero (2022). They then released the maxi-single Luminescent Bridge (2023) which saw them combining elements from both their progressive death metal and ambient work. Luminescent Bridge's two songs are included on the deluxe edition of Absolute Elsewhere as a bonus disc as is a second completely ambient release not currently available elsewhere calls All Gates Open.

Absolute Elsewhere is a very different beast to either of the previous Blood Incantation studio albums and if you haven't been paying attention to what they've been doing since Hidden History of the Human Race, it may come as a surprise but if you have been you will know that Blood Incantation isn't content to be a one trick pony. This album features just two songs (broken up into three tracks each and branded as Tablets by the band) which see them combining all different kinds of music into their sound. Expect lots of shifts between their cavernous death metal sound and lighter music, including synth driven stuff which also included a guest spot for Thorsten Quaeschning, the current band leader of Berlin School giants Tangerine Dream. As an album Absolute Elsewhere owes as much to Pink Floyd as it does Morbid Angel. Both the songs or suites, if you prefer, cross the twenty minute border.

It is simply one of those albums where there are so many intricacies present that coming back to it for more time after time again reveals more and more about it. I'm already on my twelfth listen as of putting this review together. While it may need saying that they might be now too far gone for the more purist of death metal fans, for whom these continual let-ups in the intensity may serve as unnecessary distraction, I don't feel that Blood Incantation has moved into the world better described as extreme progressive metal as inhabited by Opeth or Ihsahn: they leave no doubt over their death metal allegiances when they're really giving it welly. This is death metal, just enhanced into a cosmic experience, taking you through stargates to deliver it's message. I am floored by it.

For me, Blood Incantation just released in Absolute Elsewhere not only their best album yet, but also one of the most outright interesting death metal albums to be released for a long time. It is the album that sets the standard for the rest of the year that other bands are going to have to better if they are to dethrone it from being my top album of 2024.

FROZEN CROWN War Hearts

Album · 2024 · Power Metal
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
For my money Italy's Frozen Crown number among the best power metal bands to have made their debut within the last ten years. They do not necessarily break the mould but then, it's power metal. There are certain expectations that need to be delivered if a band is going to be considered a really good power metal act: speed, melody, great vocals and infectious songs. Frozen Crown has that in spades and this time with their fifth studio album War Hearts (2024) they're following suit with the modern Iron Maiden line-up and coming at us with a triple guitarist attack.

That probably means more in the live environment than it does in the studio, but the addition of Alessia Lanzone is another skilled and talented musician in the Frozen Crown family and we've already seen the trio in action in the music videos made to promote War Hearts (Steel and Gold was the first released song, followed by the title track) and that's enough to show that a three guitarist line-up is not overkill.

The rest of the band's line-up remains unchanged from that of Call of the North (2023): Giada "Jade" Etro (vocals), Federico Mondelli (guitars, vocals), Fabiola Bellomo (guitars), Francesco Zof (bass) and Niso Tomasini (drums).

Opening with the two singles, Frozen Crown more or less sticks to a formula aside from a shorter penultimate instrumental leading into the album's sole longer and closing track Ice Dragon. I cannot say that the ten track album throws much in the way of surprise if one is familiar with Frozen Crown already, or even just with power metal music. In the past the band has experimented a bit with using some extremer elements but those are absent on War Hearts and in fact secondary vocalist Federico Mondelli doesn't really sing all that much at all but that's perhaps hardly surprising when they have Giada Etro as their main vocalist. Frozen Crown's musicianship is superb, but for me Etro is the band's biggest draw. It is the singer that can make or break a power metal band. You can hear that Frozen Crown knows how good of a singer they have in Giada.

Frozen Crown's discography so far has been a solidly consistent one and War Hearts is not going to be the album that bucks that trend, which is actually a double-edged sword because while it's another excellent power metal album featuring all those hallmark elements I mentioned earlier, I also can't fairly say that it's the Frozen Crown album that really takes their music to the next level – although perhaps the most outright disappointing thing about it is that it's their shortest studio album to date, being over ten minutes shorter than Call of the North despite having the same amount of tracks. But I meant what I said about them being among the best modern power metal bands – they are. They just haven't, for me at least, yet released an album I'd feel comfortable giving a 5 star score to.

But a fifth 4.5 in a row is hardly anything to be sniffed at. And they're going to get there to the top tier sooner rather than later, I think. They have the musicianship, the excellent singer and they have the power metal sound down to a tee. If anything what's held me back with how I score their work is that they may actually be too polished even for a power metal band. It's taken the edge off the raw energy that this kind of music is capable of having. It's the difference, I think, between a power metal album that power metal fans like me are going to lap up and a power metal album that can make those less enthusiastic about the genre pay attention.

BLIND GUARDIAN Somewhere Far Beyond - Revisited

Album · 2024 · Power Metal
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
You Can't Improve Perfection...

...But You Can Do It Justice.

Blind Guardian re-recording Somewhere Far Beyond, one of their best and most beloved of albums that was originally released in 1992, has to be one of, if not THE most pointless of exercises that any metal band could set-out to undertake. The original album already has a remastered version done in 2007 and it still sounds as good as it ever did in 2024.

I get that the Revisited version of Somewhere Far Beyond is to be treated as something of a (slightly belated) 30th anniversary celebration but that is perhaps something better celebrated with the accompanying live version that is a full performance of the album. That has been released separately as a digital download otherwise it is found on disc in the boxset version along with a blu-ray of the same performance (Rock Hard Festival 2022) and one other (Hellfest Festival 2022). But there feels little reason to buy the Revisited album itself if you already own a copy of Somewhere Far Beyond. The original is power metal perfection. A new version just cannot compare.

But at the end of the day it is still Somewhere Far Beyond, one of the greatest power metal albums anyone ever made and giving it anything less than the full five stars would be mean-spirited. It's actually a cracking performance from a band who are more than three decades older and a couple of line-up changes down the line. They do it justice. There is a moment here and there where the ears pick up and something doesn't feel quite right but a lot of the time it can be forgotten that you're listening to a re-recording. The heaviness of the original hasn't been sacrificed. The production hasn't been too over polished in a modern way. Hansi Kürsch still sounds absolutely incredible, but hey, we knew that from their continued work including their last album The God Machine.

Is it worth owning? If for some reason you can't get your hands on a copy of the original album then absolutely. Definitely if you want the live stuff on disc and not just a download and doubly so if you want the blu-ray, which I think has to surely be the biggest draw the more expensive triple disc package. But I can't lie, I can't see myself personally choosing to listen to it over the original. Somewhere Far Beyond is one of my most played albums of all time. It ranks second on my Last.fm account where Blind Guardian is my most played band overall. To start listening to a new version more than it now would almost feel like some sort of betrayal. Not that Blind Guardian has betrayed their legacy by remaking it, but on a very personal level, for me, it would feel that way. Maybe other fans will get what I mean.

EPICA Omega Alive

Movie · 2021 · Symphonic Metal
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
A Unique Experience

Covid-19 and the world going into lockdown to combat the spread of the virus looked to have sounded the death knell for live music, but modern technology allowed artists to connect with audiences remotely and many bands put on shows with no live audience in attendance. Many have since seen physical and/or digital download releases as official live albums but many also are effectively little more than watching a band do a rehearsal or in-studio performance. Omega Alive by the Dutch symphonic metal act Epica is not such a release. This is a unique live experience, sans crowd, that perhaps couldn't have been pulled off any other way.

Released in support of their eighth main (ninth overall) studio album Omega (2021), Omega Alive naturally features a setlist that is dominated by tracks from that album, with seven out of fifteen tacks taken from it alongside choice cuts from the back catalogue including The Obsessive Devotion, Cry for the Moon and Kingdom of Heaven Part 1, which they play back to back with Kingdom of Heaven Part 3. There's no The Quantum Enigma – Kingdom of Heaven Part 2, sadly, but the the back to back performance of the bookends of the song trilogy are quite something as is. Perhaps the biggest surprise in the setlist is the inclusion of In All Conscience, a bonus track available on certain versions of The Quantum Enigma (2014) album that not every listener of Epica may have on their copy of that album.

But it's not just a great setlist that makes Omega Alive such a great live release, it's the entire spectacle. The concert is interlaced with pre-filmed inserts bringing a narrative to the show, which is presented in chapters. The set-up allows the band to have their stage rearranged between each segment (and lots of outfit changes for Simone Simons) while they bring on dancers, acrobats and other stunt performers (which Simone got in on the act a bit during The Obsessive Devotion by appearing to plummet off the back of the stage), pyro effects (including at one point appearing to literally set Coen Janssen's piano on fire while he keeps playing which looks a little too real for comfort). A live children's choir appears for The Skeleton Key while Simone performs Rivers with a host of guest choir singers in a haunting a capella version. They even make use of a sprinkler system which drenches and makes the band look like they're played in a monsoon. A bit cringe considering all the electric instruments being used actually.

But what really clenches it for Omega Alive is just how on form the band is. Coen Janseen is the unexpected show stealer with a manic performance complete with burning piano (I'm still unconvinced that wasn't real) but every band member is giving it their all and clearly having a blast despite the adversity of the world situation at the time. There is really not a fault to be had as Epica showcase different sides to themselves from their softest to their heaviest, most death metal influenced material via their most progressive epics.

Epica have come across as a special band to me ever since I first heard them through The Divine Conspiracy (2007) album and Omega Alive further cements their reputation as one of the best symphonic metal acts we have, one whom should really at this point be considered to have surpassed the bigger, more popular acts that paved the way in the genre. I think I'll be watching this captivating show again sooner rather than later.

WINTERHORDE Neptunian

Album · 2023 · Melodic Black Metal
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
It's a rare album review where I can still remember certain comments I made about it years after the fact, but that's the case for me with the previous album of Israel's Winterhorde, Maestro (2016). I remember the spiel of excitement I formed my review's introduction around, talking about how getting certain albums in my inbox from labels or promoters would lead to that album being given absolute priority to. Maestro was one such album and naturally Neptunian (2023), generated the same excitement. Make no mistake about Winterhorde: these guys are damn good. I also remember how I ended that review though, lamenting how it had been six years since Underwatermoon (2010) and hoping that it wouldn't take another six years before we heard a follow-up. Turns out it's taken seven. I guess some bands just aren't going to be as productive as others and as they have been releasing albums of such a high standard, it was okay.

It was okay...until Neptunian.

As I listened to the album for the first time, I felt my excitement gradually fading, replaced by shock, confusion and horror. What had happened to the band that made those amazing earlier albums? What had made them deliver THIS as their long awaited fourth studio album?

(Sighs deeply, trying to regain composure)

Okay, so Neptunian isn't a bad sounding release per se. But it's an extremely underwhelming one that seems to contain none of the kind of special character I've come to expect from Winterhorde's compositions that made particularly the Underwatermoon and Maestro albums such a joy to listen to. The progressive flair that defined those albums seemed watered down to the point of being swallowed by the ocean's tides, leaving a melodic/symphonic black metal album behind that, while far from terrible, just isn't that exciting to listen to.

If this album were from a new band releasing their debut and I heard it they might pass me by with a few lukewarm comments about potential, but this is a new album from Winterhorde. They're a band which had previously figuratively put my jaw firmly on the floor with their progressive take on melodic black metal. Twice. The expectations for such a band are higher, as is the standard I hold them to, which also makes the disappointment in this case so much worse. Coupled with the waiting time factor of seven years, this makes Neptunian one of those things that does not seem worth it no matter what angle I try to look at it from.

And my word I hate saying that about this band, I really do. I bloody love these guys. I meant what I said in my opener to this review that they are damn good. I own all three of their prior albums and while I don't give as much playtime to their debut Nebula (2006), both Underwatermoon and Maestro get spun regularly. Unfortunately Neptunian just doesn't hold a candle to them, despite repeated spins in hope that it's one of those albums that may not wow at first but improves with familiarity.

Sadly it was not.

Latest Forum Topic Posts

  • Posted 11 hours ago in Recently Watched Films
    Seen it before but been a while. An unusual western in that both the lead and the principle villain are women. First heard the theme song in the game Fallout New Vegas.
  • Posted 2 days ago in Now -- what are you listening to? V3
    https://www.metalmusicarchives.com/album/vuur(netherlands)/in-this-moment-we-are-free-cities
  • Posted 2 days ago in Now -- what are you listening to? V3
    https://www.metalmusicarchives.com/album/king-gizzard-and-the-lizard-wizard/12-bar-bruiseI haven't heard one album yet from these guys that sounds like another they're done.This is the first one I've heard from them I'm not really digging the style of too much. It's okay I guess, but I can't see me being much inclined to revisit this one. 

Shouts

Please login to post a shout
No shouts posted yet. Be the first member to do so above!

MMA TOP 5 Metal ALBUMS

Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm
Albums with 30 ratings and more
Master of Puppets Thrash Metal
METALLICA
Buy this album from our partners
Paranoid Heavy Metal
BLACK SABBATH
Buy this album from our partners
Moving Pictures Hard Rock
RUSH
Buy this album from our partners
Powerslave NWoBHM
IRON MAIDEN
Buy this album from our partners
Rising Heavy Metal
RAINBOW
Buy this album from our partners

New Metal Artists

New Metal Releases

Hin helga kvöl Atmospheric Sludge Metal
SÓLSTAFIR
Buy this album from MMA partners
The Cycles of Suffering Black Metal
BURIAL OATH
Buy this album from MMA partners
Facilis Descensus Averno Death Metal
SAEVUS FINIS
Buy this album from MMA partners
Merciless Crossover Thrash
BODY COUNT
Buy this album from MMA partners
More new releases

New Metal Online Videos

More videos

New MMA Metal Forum Topics

More in the forums

New Site interactions

More...

Latest Metal News

members-submitted

More in the forums

Social Media

Follow us